The Real Time VAT Project - presentation by Chris Williams
• €300 million per day lost in VAT fraud -
• How to halve that by moving to real time
• Cut the Administrative Burden for companies –
• And tax authorities
• EU, USA and the rest of the world – which first?
Presentation for IBC's 15th Annual VAT & Financial Services Conference 24/03/2010 VAT: CUTTING EDGE DEVELOPMENTS
Chris Williams heads the non-profit group RTvat which has created an efficient vehicle for tax authorities to counter Carousel and other Missing Trader fraud. His experience in banking and the derivatives
markets, along with a team of fraud analysis and transaction processing
experts, has brought about the option for tax authorities to greatly
reduce this enormous hole in EU financing.
RTvat: A real-time solution for improving the EU Emissions Trading Scheme, removing intra-EU Carousel fraud and reducing other financial vulnerabilities
Presentation to European Commission's Anti Tax Fraud group in Brussels 05/11/09
Chris Williams and Richard Gray
Blog news from RTvat:
> Serious losses in VAT confirmed at over €100 billion per year
> European Commission focuses on real time VAT collection
> Commission makes call for tenders on the feasibility of new methods for collecting VAT through modern technologies
> VAT Carousel Fraud issues highlighted in the EU Emissions Trading Scheme
RTvat real-time tax solutions
From its initial focus on the specific problem of VAT fraud within the EU, RTvat has expanded its non-profit consultancy service to incorporate all areas of tax under-collection and fraud. The use of modern technology can bring about dramatic increases in tax revenue, while reducing the administrative burden for tax payers and collectors alike.
For developing countries there is an opportunity to overhaul the tax administration at a fundamental level without the obstacle of outdated or legacy systems, moving directly to electronic collection and reporting. While changing from cash-based economies can be difficult at the consumer level, the encouragement of e-invoicing for B2B transactions can bring about simple, real time tax collection options.
VAT Collection
VAT fraud has been identified as a significant EU-wide problem, with current estimates showing costs to EU governments of over €120 billion per annum in lost tax, of which €25 billion is viewed as being directly linked to carousel fraud.
This is money paid by the taxpayer which is being lost to the EU member state governments and put into the hands of criminals and fraudsters; just think what could be done with €325 million per day if it were channelled into schools, hospitals, charities or leisure and community projects. Alternatively, it's been estimated that if all the lost fraud were recovered, VAT could be cut by over 1% across the board.
The collection of VAT on behalf of national tax authorities imposes an increasingly difficult and time-consuming adminsitrative burden on businesses both large and small, and the collection and reporting systems are largely unchanged since the tax was first introduced in the 1950's.
The Real-Time Solution
At RTvat, we believe there is a simple, effective and cost-efficient way to stamp out the opportunity for tax fraud and recover the billions of euros currently being lost, as well as significantly reducing the administrative and reporting requirements. It requires a change in the way that tax is collected and accounted for, moving away from a system based on invoices - which is complicated, creates a mismatch between business settlement cycles and tax settlements which is exploited by fraudsters and creates the need for many adjustments - and towards a system based on actual settlement of the transaction.
Using technologies and control systems that are already well-established in the credit card industry and where relatively little re-scaling or re-configuration would be required, this can be achieved at low cost and with little difficulty for companies. The resulting system will meet the 2012 Lisbon target for the reduction of bureaucracy for all businesses.
An intra-EU VAT solution of this kind will eradicate all carousel fraud and, at the same time, ensure a level playing field for all companies.
In order to make this happen, we need the agreement and political will of all of the member states – and we need it quickly, so that we stop this enormous loss happening every day. It’s a simple and quick solution to a growing problem and could be put into place within just a couple of years.
Other taxes
The advantages of Real-Time collection can be applied not only to indirect taxes such as VAT but equally to a range of other national and international central financial collection and distribution systems, including for example PAYE, Corporation Tax, Commodity Taxes, Customs Duty and even Benefits Payments. RTvat is working proactively with a number of governments and organisations to develop systems which are efficient, effective and resistant to fraud. See www.rtpay.org
Emissions Trading
The current and proposed systems of Emissions Trading in the EU and worldwide has been shown to be flawed and prone to fraud, with a number of major VAT carousel frauds already exposed leading to urgent and unilateral changes in tax law by a number of nations. At RTvat we are working with interested parties at all levels to design new systems making use of Real-Time technology that will ensure smooth and effective running of the Emissions Trading schemes.
To find out more about our Real-Time tax solutions, contact us.
"Other industries can manage Real-Time settlement with no problems, and have been doing so for years. There's no reason why we can't process tax payments in the same way."
Chris Williams, Executive Committee Chairman, RTvat |